If you are about to hire a marketing agency for your advisory firm, this guide is for you. It gives you the questions to ask and the answers that should worry you.
By the end, you will know:
- What you are actually paying for, which is not ads
- The one question that tells you in thirty seconds whether they understand your business
- What good looks like at every step, so you can check their numbers against something
- When the right answer is to hire nobody
My name is Alex Khassa, founder of Clients Blackbox. We run Meta ads for fiduciary RIAs, and that is all we do. So I am one of the agencies you might be looking at. Read this knowing that, and judge the questions on whether they are good questions.
Since 2021 our system has booked more than 50,000 retiree appointments and built a $75B AUM pipeline. We have spent more than $12 million on Meta across 250+ firms and 5,000+ ads. Inc. ranked us No. 641 on the 2026 Inc. 5000.
What You Are Actually Buying
Most advisors think they are buying ads. You are not.
An ad does not book anybody. What books a retiree onto your calendar is a chain, and every link has to hold.
- A 90 second video ad with your own people in it, not stock footage.
- A 10 minute teaching video, free to watch, with no email gate in front of it.
- A booking page that screens for your asset minimum before anyone reaches an advisor.
- A confirmation video and reminders, so the people who book actually turn up.
Break any one of those and the whole thing stops working. Great ads into a bad booking page produce nothing. A perfect booking page behind a boring video produces nothing either.
So when you are interviewing an agency, you are not asking whether they can make ads. You are asking whether they can build and run that whole chain.
Ask them to walk you through all four steps. If they only want to talk about the ad, they are selling you one link and leaving you the other three.
The Four Kinds of Agency
There are four kinds of company that will answer your call, and they do very different jobs.
The media buyer. They run your ad account. You supply the videos, the page, the booking system and the follow up. If you already have all of that, this is cheap and sensible. If you do not, you have hired a driver for a car you have not bought.
The brand shop. Logo, website, colors, messaging, maybe a newsletter. Real work, and it produces no appointments. Hire them when your firm looks dated, not when your calendar is empty.
The generalist performance agency. They run ads for dentists, law firms, gyms and you. They know ads. They do not know what a sequence of returns problem is, why your compliance officer cares about the word guaranteed, or why a $75 appointment can be worse than a $450 one.
The specialist. They work only with advisory firms. Narrower, and they have already made the expensive mistakes on somebody else's money.
None of these is wrong. They are answers to different problems. The mistake is hiring a brand shop when you needed appointments, or a media buyer when you had nothing for them to run.
Work out which problem you have before you take a single call.
The Question That Sorts Them Fast
Here is the one I would open with.
"What is a booked appointment worth to my firm, and how did you work that out?"
Watch what happens. A good answer starts with your numbers, not theirs. Your average account size. Your fee. How long you keep a client. Your close rate. Then it works backward to what you can afford to pay for a meeting.
A weak answer goes straight to their price, or to a cost per lead they got for somebody else.
Why this question works: an agency that cannot do your math will optimize for the only number it understands, which is cheap leads. And cheap leads are how you end up with a calendar full of people who have nothing to invest.
I will say this plainly because it costs us money to say it. The cheapest appointment is usually the worst one. Wealthier retirees cost more to put a message in front of. Tell an ad platform to find you cheap bookings and it will go and find people whose attention is cheap, and attention is cheap when there is not much money behind it.
If an agency opens by promising to drive your cost per lead down, ask them what happens to the quality when they do.
Ask Who Is on Camera
This one separates people fast.
"Who appears in the video, and who writes what they say?"
The answer should be one of your advisors, on camera, teaching a real problem. Not an actor. Not a voiceover over stock footage of a couple walking on a beach.
Here is why that matters. Retirees do not hire a firm. They hire a person. Your prospect needs to watch somebody explain a problem they are worried about, and decide they want that person looking at their situation.
So ask what they need from your team. The honest answer is a few hours of recording every few months. If an agency tells you they need nothing from your advisors at all, ask who is going to be in the video.
One of our clients had used a firm that made him build his own ads. He spent $100,000 and never got a single qualified appointment. The ads were not the problem. Nobody from his firm was ever in them.
On Meta, your creative is your targeting. The platform's settings do less sorting than you would expect, especially in financial services. The video does the sorting. The people who stop and watch a video about retirement tax planning are the people who have that problem.
Ask What Happens After the Click
Most agencies will show you ads. Fewer will show you what happens next.
Ask to see a landing page they built. Then ask these:
- Is the teaching video gated behind an email form? It should not be. You are asking a stranger to trade their details before you have given them anything.
- How many videos are on the page? One. Put three up and fewer people watch any of them, and watching the video is what makes somebody book.
- What happens between booking and the meeting? There should be a confirmation, reminders, and a video so the prospect knows who they are about to meet.
- What happens to the people who do not show up? There should be a way back onto the calendar.
That last one gets skipped constantly, and it is pure waste. You paid for that appointment whether they turned up or not.
Ask How They Handle Your Minimum
If your minimum is $500,000 and you are getting $100,000 prospects, that is not ideal. The fix is simple and almost nobody does it.
Put your minimum in the ad, on the video page, and on the booking page.
Say it three times. Some people will drop out. That is the point. You are paying for advisor hours, and an advisor sitting with somebody who was never going to qualify is the most expensive thing in your business.
So ask the agency: "Where does my minimum appear, and what screening sits in front of my calendar?"
If the answer is that they will filter leads afterwards by phone, you are paying your own team to do the filtering the booking page should have done.
And ask what happens when a prospect does not qualify. There should be an answer that is not just hanging up on them.
Ask What Good Looks Like to Them
Any agency can say a campaign is working. Ask them what number they are measuring it against, at each step.
Here is what we look for, so you have something to compare their answer to.
- About half of booked prospects show up to the fit call.
- About three quarters of those book a discovery meeting.
- About three quarters of those show up to it.
- Around a third close, for a firm advertising in its own local market.
On cost, a local booked call runs around $450. Nationwide runs closer to $250.
Now look at that local number again. It is nearly double. And local firms close at a much better rate, because the prospect already knows the name and can drive to the office. The expensive appointment is often the better buy, which is exactly why cost per lead is a bad way to judge an agency.
Those are our numbers, not a law of nature. Your market, your minimum and your advisors will move them. The point is that an agency should have numbers like this and be able to tell you where you are against them, step by step. If the only number in the report is cost per lead, you cannot tell where the funnel is leaking.
Ask Who Owns Everything If You Leave
Ask this before you sign, not after three years of spending.
"If we stop working together, what do we keep?"
The list should be: the ad account, the videos, the landing pages, the booking system, the tracking, and the data. All of it should be in your name from day one.
Think about the money you gave somebody five years ago. Is any of it still working for you today? If the answer is no, you were renting. Every dollar you spend should leave something behind that belongs to your firm.
Ask where the ad account lives. Ask who the videos belong to. Ask whether the landing pages sit on your domain. Get the answers in writing.
Ask How They Work With Compliance
Your compliance officer is going to see everything before it runs. An agency that has not thought about that will cost you months.
Ask them how review fits into their production schedule. Ask who submits materials, how versions are tracked, and what happens when a change is requested after something is approved.
Then ask them what they will not do. A good agency has a list. No promises about returns. No promissory language. Education about a real financial problem rather than a pitch dressed up as education.
And be careful with anyone who tells you their ads are compliant. They are not the ones who decide that. Your compliance process and your counsel decide, and the agency's job is to work inside it and keep good records.
If an agency pushes you to approve faster because a launch date is coming, that is the whole answer to the question you were asking.
When Not to Hire Anyone
Sometimes the right move is to wait. Here is when.
Your advisors have no room. This books meetings in volume. If nobody can take them, you are paying for appointments that sit empty.
Nobody owns the follow up. A prospect who asks for information at 10am and gets a first call two days later is gone. Decide who owns incoming prospects before you turn anything on.
You cannot say who a good prospect is. If the firm cannot agree on a minimum, the campaign cannot screen for one.
Compliance takes weeks for every change. Find that out before you commit the budget, not in month two.
You want somebody to guarantee you clients. Nobody can. An agency can be accountable for appointments and for the work it agreed to do. It cannot run your discovery meetings.
None of those are reasons to never advertise. They are reasons to fix the thing first. An agency that tells you to go sort your follow up out before you spend money with them is showing you how they will behave later.
Want this built and run for your firm? If your RIA manages $100M or more with three or more advisors, and you want predictable, scalable AUM growth instead of waiting on referrals, take the short survey to see if you qualify.
FAQ
How much does a financial advisor marketing agency cost?
It depends what you are buying. A media buyer who only runs your ad account costs far less than a firm building your videos, pages, booking system and follow up, because they are doing far less. Ask what is included and what you still have to build yourself. Our own system starts at $17,500 a month, all in. Whatever you are quoted, work out what a client is worth to you first, then judge the price against that rather than against what feels comfortable.
How long before an agency produces appointments?
First appointments usually arrive within a week or two of launch. Full volume takes one to two months while the campaign ramps and your team settles into the process. New assets arrive on your sales cycle, not your marketing's. Judge the first quarter on what appointments cost and who is showing up. Anyone promising you a date for closed AUM is guessing.
Should I hire a generalist or a specialist?
A generalist who is good at ads can absolutely run ads. What they have not done is sit through a compliance review for an advisory firm, or learn why a cheap appointment can be the worst thing that happened to your month. You will pay for that learning either way. The question is whether you pay for it with your budget or somebody paid for it already.
Can I just run this in house?
Yes, and some firms do. What you need is somebody who can write and test ads continuously, build and maintain the pages, run the booking and reminder system, handle compliance review, and read the numbers at every step. If you have that person, keep them. Most firms find the hard part is not the first campaign. It is producing fresh creative every month without pulling advisors out of meetings.
Want this built and run for your firm?
If your RIA manages $100M or more with three or more advisors, and you want predictable, scalable AUM growth instead of waiting on referrals, take the short survey to see if you qualify.
Since 2021 our system has booked more than 50,000 retiree appointments and built a $75B AUM pipeline. The average retiree we book holds $1.5 million in investable assets. We write, edit, and run everything. Your advisors shoot short videos and take the meetings.